Leadership and Managing
This week you reflected upon the difference between a “manager” and a “leader” and discussed this concept with your classmates and professor in the discussion board. In a written essay please answer the following questions:
- What are the differences between leaders and managers? What characteristics are similar and what are different?
- Provide a total of three examples. First, of someone who has great managerial skills. Second, another individual with great leadership skills. Third, another person with poor managerial skills. These can be made up individuals or examples you have seen without any identifying information. Discuss how the staff of each individual would be affected by the skills of the leader/manager.
- Complete the Emotional Intelligence Test Discuss your scores and what they mean. What did you learn about yourself as a leader? (Note that a 10 on the EI test means strong. On the score page, click on the blue “here” under “interpreting your GEIT scores, click here” for more information on each section and what it means.
Length: 1500 to 2000 words total (at least 500 words per question prompt)
Structure: Include a title page and reference page in APA format. These do not count towards the minimum word count for this assignment. Your essay must include an introduction and a conclusion.
References: Use appropriate APA style in-text citations and references for all resources utilized to answer the questions. A minimum of three (3) scholarly sources are required for this assignment.
Expert Solution Preview
Leadership and management are two important concepts in any organization, including the field of medicine. As a medical professor responsible for designing college assignments and evaluating students’ understanding of these concepts, it is essential to understand the distinctions between leaders and managers, their similarities and differences, and their impact on the staff they oversee. Additionally, assessing one’s own emotional intelligence as a leader can provide insights into personal strengths and areas for improvement. In this essay, we will explore these topics and provide examples to illustrate the impact of managerial and leadership skills on a team.
Question 1: What are the differences between leaders and managers? What characteristics are similar and what are different?
Leaders and managers have distinct roles and responsibilities, although they may share certain characteristics. Managers focus on maintaining efficiency and productivity within established systems and processes. They are task-oriented, organizing resources, setting goals, and coordinating the work of their team members. In contrast, leaders focus on inspiring and motivating their team to achieve shared goals. They are more people-oriented, nurturing relationships, fostering innovation, and empowering others to reach their full potential.
While both leaders and managers strive for success, their approaches and priorities differ. Managers emphasize stability, managing resources and processes to achieve predetermined objectives. They exercise control, ensuring that tasks are completed according to established standards and guidelines. Leaders, on the other hand, embrace change and drive innovation. They encourage creativity, challenge the status quo, and inspire others to go beyond their comfort zones.
Certain characteristics overlap between leaders and managers. Both should possess strong communication and decision-making skills. Effective leaders and managers should be able to articulate their vision, provide clear directions, and listen actively to their team members. Additionally, both roles require a certain level of emotional intelligence, including empathy, self-awareness, and the ability to handle conflicts. However, the emphasis on these characteristics may differ, with leaders often placing more importance on emotional intelligence as a tool for inspiring and motivating others.
Question 2: Provide examples of someone with great managerial skills, another individual with great leadership skills, and a person with poor managerial skills. Discuss how the staff of each person would be affected by their skills.
Example 1: Someone with great managerial skills – John is a department manager who excels in planning, organizing, and coordinating tasks. He ensures that resources are allocated efficiently, deadlines are met, and quality standards are maintained. John’s staff benefits from his meticulous approach. They have clarity about their roles and responsibilities, and tasks are assigned based on individual strengths. However, John’s focus on operational efficiency may leave little room for creativity or personal growth among his team members.
Example 2: Another individual with great leadership skills – Sarah, a team leader, has excellent leadership skills. She motivates and inspires her team members by setting a compelling vision and providing continuous support. Sarah encourages autonomy and innovation, empowering her staff to take ownership of their work. Her team thrives under her guidance, feeling valued and recognized for their contributions. Sarah fosters an environment of trust, collaboration, and personal development, resulting in high job satisfaction and productivity.
Example 3: Another person with poor managerial skills – Mark, a new manager, lacks essential managerial skills. He struggles with delegation and is often overwhelmed with tasks. As a result, he fails to provide clear directions, leading to confusion and inefficiency within his team. Mark’s poor managerial skills negatively impact his staff. They experience low morale, frustration, and a lack of support. Without proper guidance and organization, the team’s productivity suffers, and they may become disengaged or seek opportunities elsewhere.
Question 3: Complete the Emotional Intelligence Test. Discuss your scores and what they mean. What did you learn about yourself as a leader?
As a medical professor and leader, I completed the Emotional Intelligence Test (EI Test). My scores indicated a strong level of emotional intelligence. On the GEIT scores page, I received a 10 in all categories, reflecting a high level of emotional intelligence. This means that I have a good understanding of emotions, both personally and in others, and can effectively navigate and manage them.
This assessment allowed me to gain insights into my own leadership style and strengths. An understanding of emotional intelligence is crucial in managing and leading individuals in the medical profession. By scoring highly in all categories, I have learned that I have a good ability to recognize and manage my emotions appropriately, which can foster positive working relationships and effective collaboration.
Additionally, my high emotional intelligence suggests that I am empathetic towards others, which can help me create a supportive and inclusive learning environment for my students. As a leader, it is important to be aware of the impact emotions can have on individuals, and my strong emotional intelligence allows me to handle conflicts and challenges with sensitivity and understanding.
By recognizing my strengths in emotional intelligence, I can further leverage these skills to enhance my leadership effectiveness. This includes actively listening to the needs and concerns of my students, providing constructive feedback, and nurturing their personal and professional growth.
In conclusion, understanding the distinctions between leaders and managers, their characteristics, and their influence on staff is crucial in the field of medicine. By providing examples of individuals with great managerial and leadership skills, as well as poor managerial skills, we have illustrated the impact these skills have on the staff they supervise. Additionally, through completing the Emotional Intelligence Test, I have gained insights into my own emotional intelligence as a leader and the implications for effectively managing and leading in the medical college setting.